• About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Friday, November 20, 2026
No Result
View All Result
MVSKOKE Media
Subscribe Now
  • Home
  • News
  • Editorial
  • Featured
  • Archives
    • Newspaper Archives
    • Radio
    • Vision
  • Creative
    • Advertising
    • Policies
  • Contact
  • Market
  • Home
  • News
  • Editorial
  • Featured
  • Archives
    • Newspaper Archives
    • Radio
    • Vision
  • Creative
    • Advertising
    • Policies
  • Contact
  • Market
No Result
View All Result
MVSKOKE Media
No Result
View All Result

Oral arguments held in MCN v. Kunzweiler appeal

United States Tenth Circuit heard arguments concerning Tulsa County District Attorney Steve Kunzweiler’s jurisdiction

by Jerrad Moore
November 20, 2026
in Featured, Home Feature, News, Newsletter
0
Oral arguments held in MCN v. Kunzweiler appeal

MM

 

DENVER – The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit heard oral arguments in the appeal of the opinion and order handed down in Muscogee Creek Nation v. Kunzweiler last year.  

In Nov. 2025, MCN filed a motion for a preliminary injunction against Tulsa County District Attorney Steve Kunzweiler, seeking to prevent him from asserting concurrent criminal jurisdiction over non-Mvskoke Tribal members within the Mvskoke Reservation. As previously reported, the United States District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma denied this motion.

This decision was appealed to the Tenth Circuit, which held oral arguments on the matter on Nov. 17.

The appeal was heard by Judges Harris Hartz, David Ebel, and Carolyn McHugh. MCN was represented by Riyaz A. Kanji. Kannon K. Shanmugam represented Kunzweiler. A recording of the oral arguments is available on the Mvskoke Media YouTube channel.

Kanji began the arguments by pointing out that three recent cases before the Tenth Circuit have resulted in rulings upholding the longstanding rule that states cannot exercise jurisdiction over Indians in Indian Country. Kanji pointed out that these rulings also matched the statutory enactments that provide that the Indians in question do not have to be members of the Tribe for that Tribe to have jurisdiction over them.

Kanji then pointed out that state courts can have jurisdiction over Indians in Indian Country under Public Law 280, but that requires the Tribe in question to consent. Kanji suggested Oklahoma’s attempt to assert unilateral jurisdiction over Indians in Indian Country was not supported by any legal precedent or federal statute.

Kanji then addressed the argument that concurrent jurisdiction does not harm Tribal sovereignty. He highlighted that an essential aspect of Tribal decision-making is prosecutorial discretion. Prosecutorial discretion refers to the legal principle that the prosecutor in a case decides whether to charge a person with a crime and what charges to file.  

Kanji pointed out that when the state claims unilateral jurisdiction over Indians, it renders the Tribal prosecutor’s discretion irrelevant, as the state prosecutor can decide to proceed with prosecution or charge the defendant with different crimes.

Kanji referred to a policy instituted by Tulsa Sheriff Vic Regalato that stated that if a Tribal citizen was arrested who as not an MCN citizen, then they would be sent to state court. According to Kanji this was not concurrent jurisdiction, but instead amounted to exclusive jurisdiction.

Kanji then noted that a defendant who was sentenced to attend a substance abuse rehab program as a part of Tribal court proceedings could also end up in state jail, which would result in their inability to complete their Tribal court sentence.

During Kanji’s arguments, Judge McHugh asked that he address the Castro-Huerta decision. Judge Hugh pointed out that the decision seemed to indicate a presumption of concurrent jurisdiction. 

Kanji answered that the decision stated that states exercise jurisdiction except where preempted by federal law or the principles of Tribal self-government. Kanji reiterated that in the Castro-Huerta case, the state was not prosecuting Indians, so there was no conflict of concurrent jurisdiction.

Shanmugam represented Kunzweiler and began his arguments by asserting that the Castro-Huerta decision gave the state jurisdiction over non-Indian defendants on the Mvskoke Reservation. Shanmugam asserted that there is no legal difference between a non-Indian defendant and a non-Mvskoke Indian defendant on the Mvskoke Reservation.

Judge McHugh pointed out that Congress uses the language “Indians” to refer to all Indians, not members of a particular Tribe. 

Shanmugam stated that when Congress amended the Indian Civil Rights Act in 1991 to explicitly confer jurisdiction on Tribal governments over non-member Indians, it did not intend to strip the state of jurisdiction over the same defendants. This amendment is referred to as the “Duro-Fix” after the Supreme Court decision in Duro v. Reina.

Judge Hartz pointed out that, since Congress was conferring jurisdiction on Tribes in these instances, it can be inferred that Congress did not intend for the states to have jurisdiction.

Judge McHugh stated that courts have ruled that states lack jurisdiction over Indians. McHugh said, “You don’t have to strip it, if it never existed.”

Shanmugam argued that it is not a settled proposition and that the assumption that states do not have jurisdiction was not codified in law.

Judge Hartz asked if historical Supreme Court decisions reflected a hostility toward states exercising jurisdiction over Indians in Indian Territory regardless of Tribal membership.

Shanmugam conceded that was correct, but asserted that the Court has moved away from that position in the modern era. Shanmugam stated that there are not many cases concerning the prosecution of non-member Indians. In his view, the prosecution of non-member Indians was an edge case until the McGirt decision.

Shanmugam suggested that the Supreme Court wants lower courts to address the question of jurisdiction on the Mvskoke Reservation using the Castro-Huerta framework.

Judge McHugh asked why Shanmugam would cite the Bracker balancing test referenced in Castro-Huerta, when Bracker explicitly states that it is to be applied when the defendant is a non-Indian.

Shanmugam argued that Bracker is about balancing the sovereign interests of the federal government, the state, and the Tribe. The state has a sovereign interest to ensure public safety within its territory. According to Shanmugam, the Tribe has less interest in the matter, because non-member Indians are not the Tribe’s constituents. Shanmugam denied that concurrent jurisdiction usurped Tribal prosecutorial discretion. 

Judge Hartz then pointed out that concurrent jurisdiction would have significant legal implications when prosecutors have differing opinions on how a case should be charged or prosecuted.

Shanmugam agreed with this assertion and replied that concurrent jurisdiction exists practically in various forms and there are instances where all three sovereigns have jurisdiction. As an example, he used cases under the Violence Against Women Act, where in certain instances Congress conferred jurisdiction over non-Indians to Tribal governments. According to Shanmugam, these are examples of competing sovereign interests, and the state’s interests would be eliminated if it had no authority to prosecute.

Judge Hartz observed that Shanmugam seemed to be discounting the Tribal interests.

Shanmugam denied this and stated that if the state retained jurisdiction over non-member Indians, both the Tribe and state would be able to address their sovereign interests. Shanmugam asserted that if the Northern District ruling was overturned, the state would lose its ability to address its sovereign interests.

Judge Hartz asked whether Shanmugam believed there was relevant dicta from the Supreme Court in McGirt. Dicta, in a legal sense, refers to comments, observations, or suggestions made by a judge in an opinion that are not necessary to resolve the case and do not establish legal precedent.

Shanmugam stated that if there is dicta in the McGirt decision, it is weak.

Judge Hartz pushed back on this assertion, pointing out that McGirt was a Seminole Nation citizen. 

Shanmugam pointed out that the McGirt case dealt with the Major Crimes Act, so it was not applicable.

Judge McHugh asked whether, if the court upheld the Northern District Court’s ruling, states where Public Law 280 applied would have jurisdiction over non-member Indians.

Shanmugam stated they would. He then reiterated that MCN did not have Tribal self-governing interests in the case because the Indians in question were not Mvskoke citizens.

Judge Ebel asked if there was an agreed-upon definition of who is or is not an Indian and, if so, what case it is in.

Shanmugam did not know of a case and pointed out that Tribes determine their own membership with consultation with the BIA.

Judge Ebel pointed out that Tribal membership could be a very different issue from whether you are considered an Indian or not.

Shanmugam agreed.

Judge Ebel asked whether Shanmugam had any guidance on the issue, and Shanmugam deferred to Kanji. Judge Ebel asked whether there was an accepted definition, and Shanmugam stated that he did not think there was

one.

Judge Ebel pointed out that if the court ruled that MCN had jurisdiction over Indians on the Mvskoke Reservation, state officials would have no way of determining who was an Indian for jurisdictional purposes.

Judge McHugh then asked Kanji, at the beginning of his rebuttal, whether there was a definition of “Indian” that is routinely applied under the law. 

Kanji stated that the court has addressed the question many times; it is a two-pronged definition that requires some degree of Indian blood and some recognition by the Tribe.

Judge Ebel asked if the degree of Indian blood had been defined. Kanji stated no. Judge Ebel asked who gets to define it, and Kanji stated that it was a combination of the Tribes and the BIA.

In closing, Kanji focused on four main points. The first was that the Duro-Fix was enacted because states lack presumed jurisdiction over Indians regardless of Tribal membership. His second point was that Castro-Huerta delineates two ways for pre-emptive jurisdiction: ordinary federal pre-emption and pre-emption under Tribal self-government. His third point was that Oklahoma was not different from other states that had Tribal populations or reservations, and there was a long legal history of states trying to illegally assert jurisdiction over Indians. His final point was that the MCN has a robust legal system funded at a higher per-capita level than Tulsa County’s, and it is working well, according to testimony in the case from local police chiefs. Kanji argued that this was evidence that concurrent jurisdiction is not necessary to maintain public safety because the MCN is addressing that state sovereign interest in regard to non-member Indians.

Finally, Kanji pointed out the fact that this case deals only with one sheriff and one district attorney in one county. According to Kanji, the vast majority of other counties and cities in the Mvskoke Reservation are respecting MCN rights and are cooperating.

Mvskoke Media will have ongoing coverage of this developing story. 

 

ADVERTISEMENT
Jerrad Moore

Jerrad Moore

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ADVERTISEMENT

Community Calendar

Nov 10
November 10 @ 8:00 am - November 28 @ 5:00 pm

Community Art Project | what does language mean to you?

Nov 30
10:00 am - 1:00 pm

Entrepreneur 101

Dec 8
6:00 pm - 8:00 pm

Eufaula Dorms Christmas Basketball Showdown and Carnival

Dec 15
5:00 pm

MCN Natural Resource Conservation District Annual Meeting

Dec 16
8:00 am - 7:00 pm

Tulsa Creek Indian Community Special Election

View Calendar

Recommended

First MCN Elderly Nutrition Program Food Show since COVID-19

First MCN Elderly Nutrition Program Food Show since COVID-19

4 years ago
Pageant helped Barnett preserve the language

Pageant helped Barnett preserve the language

7 years ago
MVSKOKE Media

© 2020 MVSKOKE Media.

MVSKOKE Media

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact

Find Us On

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Editorial
  • Featured
  • Archives
    • Newspaper Archives
    • Radio
    • Vision
  • Creative
    • Advertising
    • Policies
  • Contact
  • Market

© 2020 MVSKOKE Media.